Ontario Agriculture

The network for agriculture in Ontario, Canada

Shaun Haney: How Ontario and the West are Different.

I have posted this commentary by our friend Shaun Haney of Alberta, he dropped in to the Farms.com office for a visit a couple of weeks ago on his trip to Ontario.



How Ontario and the West are Different.
By Shaun Haney, Realagriculture.com

I recently traveled to Ontario to attend some meetings that pertained to my seed business. I had a great time and was hosted by some great companies and people. The real treat was getting to spend some time with local retailers and farmers from all over Ontario. I always enjoy spending time with farmers and agribusiness people from different trading areas than my own because it gives me a chance to ask questions and learn.

Agriculture in Ontario has many differences from agriculture in Western Canada, and this becomes more evident the more I visit the province. Alberta and Saskatchewan have differences but not like the west and Ontario. I heard one Ontario farmer refer to the difference as black and white. One seed retailer told me that, “when you compare Ontario and Western Canadian agriculture, it’s like different countries.”

Here are a few key differences:

1. No single desk selling on wheat – This is super obvious and throws boat gas on any anti-wheat board westerner. One person told me that nothing puts Ontario farmers to sleep faster than westerners talking about the Canadian Wheat Board. The Ontario wheat market is much smaller than the west’s, but still it makes no sense to me that this difference in marketing control has transpired.

Ontario also rid itself of KVD much sooner than the west did. Apparently the Ontario wheat market is able to convince politicians to enact change much better and faster than their western farmer colleagues. Whether you are in favour of a single desk or not, it is incredibly strange that only certain regions of the country are forced to sell its wheat to a single desk entity.

2. Firmer understanding of IP markets – Due to the identity-preserved (IP) market for non-GMO edible soybeans, I find that Ontario farmers have a better grasp of quality systems and the direct impact that they have on the customer. The west does access some special crop markets in IP systems, but the soybean business is much different. Even in the wheat market in Ontario, it seems that farmers are more experienced in talking to millers. One great example was the package of whole-wheat pasta made from Ontario-grown durum that I received from my friend Archie Wilson at C&M Seeds. That’s right, Ontario durum. C&M developed a pilot project with some growers and a miller to create a locally-produced Ontario pasta product.

3. Smaller farms – Western agriculture is much bigger in farm size due to the wide open prairies. Big Ontario farms are in the 1,500- to 3,000-acre range, not the 15,000-acre range. This is partly due to the massive difference in the cost of land. I had dinner with one farmer that said land is selling in his region for up to $10,000 per acre. That kind of price will do a lot to constrict expansion. I think this issue of size is what really makes the differences interesting. The size difference directly impacts the development of agricultural policy and farm assistance programs across the country. Smaller farms also lead to smaller fields which affects land management. The way that you manage a 4000 acre field on the Blood Reserve in Alberta is different than a 80 acre field just outside Ottawa. This is what makes Canadian agriculture so diverse and challenging.

4. Larger urban influence – Farming in the Greater Toronto Area is much different than farming just outside Saskatoon or Calgary or Winnipeg. The impact of urban population on agriculture is dramatic. This year a law was passed banning all urban pesticide use. Farmers are very concerned that this is the thin edge of the wedge and banning agricultural pesticides could be next. Agriculture has real roots in areas like London and Guelph, but otherwise the urban centers have no really business connection to the farming world around them. Although the west is moving this way, the larger western cities still have some attachment to agriculture in the sense they still drive the economy in the surrounding area.

5. Main crop types – Ontario is wall to wall corn and soybeans, while the west is mainly wheat and canola. Ontario does have a fairly large crop of winter wheat, by Ontario standards, and a small amount of canola, but driving around the province you see how dominant the corn-soy rotation has become. I live in a major corn growing area in Picture Butte, Alberta, but it is nothing like Ontario where in some areas all you can see it corn. I think the fact that Canada can produce many different crops is what makes it quite unique in the global agricultural arena.

Traveling to Ontario, you begin to realize the challenge Gerry Ritz and his team have in managing the differences between east and west. Add B.C. and Quebec into the mix, and the challenge becomes that much greater. Canada is a large country, which can be a hindrance or strategic advantage. The cool thing about traveling in Canada is that whether you are in London or Lethbridge, agriculture is a very warm community of people that share the common bond of trying to feed the world. Thank you Ontario for the great visit.

Views: 37

Comment

You need to be a member of Ontario Agriculture to add comments!

Join Ontario Agriculture

Comment by Joe Dales on October 10, 2009 at 6:52am
I wonder Steve if Canadian ag policy and programs can fit the breadth and depth of Canadian Agriculture.

Do the government policy writers need to approach this diversity from a new direction?



Shaun's operation is an example...he is located in Southern Alberta near the town of Picture Butte just north of Lethbridge and in that usually arid region, there has been over 1 million acres of irrigated land developed by the farmers....they grow corn, vegetables and the regular western crops in the area...huge diversity even in the west...

How do they design programs when we live in a world of extreme volatility with a large number of commodities, wide swinging commodity prices, flucutating exchange rates and lucrative foreign gov't support programs?

Joe
Comment by Steve Twynstra on October 8, 2009 at 3:10pm
First caught this story in Grainnews. Thanks Shaun for helping to bridge the Ontario-West gap with this kind of reporting. We'll just leave Quebec out of it for now...

You commented on the challenge of creating federal agr policy and assistance. Too bad your neighbour from SK is too afraid or ignorant to set his foot in ON outside of Ottawa to witness the clear 'flexibility' needed to benefit ON. The first gaffe was to totally renege on "scrapping CAIS" which was a non-starter for the majority of Ontario farmers. Surprising considering the only other hold-out to implementing this boondoggle nationally was SK! However, for many here it has been a REAL slap in the face to contribute so effectively to the current stable in Ottawa only to have them turn on us when we need them in grains and oilseeds. By hiding behind bogus logic and claims they are not supporting our RMP... or was there another international trade-off involved? As a result, they are setting the stage for a significant rural electoral upset as soon as a viable alternative exists...

Agriculture Headlines from Farms.com Canada East News - click on title for full story

Poilievre pledges to reverse the harmful capital gains tax hike

Pierre Poilievre plans to reverse the capital gains tax hike, saving jobs and boosting Canada's economy. His strategy includes cutting wasteful corporate subsidies to promote growth and investment.

The tax impact on farmers of proroguing Parliament

Parliament is suspended, this delays key tax proposals for farmers, including changes to capital gains and the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption.

New Year, New Leadership and Look for SaskOilseeds

SaskOilseeds is celebrating its official amalgamation by launching a progressive new look! "Our new brand identity reflects SaskOilseeds' vision of growing producer prosperity," says Tracy Broughton, Executive Director of SaskOilseeds. "The thoughtful, interpretive icon starts as an outline of Saskatchewan enveloping a seedling that intentionally resembles a book, to depict the Commissions' primary priority of funding canola and flax research." SaskOilseeds' new look includes a logo complete with symbolic icon and the Commissions' new name, accompanied by a colour palette that includes nods to research with innovation green, canola with vibrant yellow and flax with rich blue, rounded out with a punchy orange to tie in Saskatchewan sunsets. "SaskOilseeds' brand identity solidifies a positive merger that will streamline operations, enhance research initiatives, and provide a unified voice for oilseed growers in the province," says Dean Roberts, Chair of SaskOilseeds who farms near Col

SaskCanola and SaskFlax merge into the brand new SaskOilSeeds

Yesterday, at the Western Canadian Crop Production Show in Saskatoon, SK, a new brand was announced. SaskCanola and SaskFlax announced that they would be amalgamating under one brand called SaskOilSeeds. While this amalgamation isn’t brand new, in fact, they officially merged together on August 1st, 2024, this announcement marks a new chapter in oilseeds for producers in Saskatchewan. Tracy Broughton is the executive director of the new SaskOilSeeds brand, and she talks about why this merger was needed, and how it will help producers of Saskatchewan oilseeds in the future. “The (SaskOilSeeds) board felt that it was a good opportunity to refresh kind of our look to the farmers and make sure that we’re speaking with one voice to reach the maximum number of farmers. In Saskatoon, during Crop Production Show week, it just seemed like a really good time to be able to present the final financials of the two organizations, SaskCanola and SaskFlax and then be able to present that new logo to

Manitoba Ag Days returns with 550+ exhibitors and exciting new features

Excitement is building for the 48th annual Manitoba Ag Days, and with the 2025 event just days away, Teresa Hildebrand, the event's media coordinator, says it promises to be similar to past years, with some fun new events.   “Everything is shaping up really well,” says Hildebrand, “We’re excited to invite everyone to the Keystone Centre in Brandon, where we’ve got over 550 exhibitors, 34 new innovations, and a great mix of returning favourites and new activities.” Kicking off with breakfast  Hildebrand notes that if you’re planning to attend the event, you’re invited to start the week of with breakfast on Tuesday morning.   “Breakfast will be served in the dome building, located just across the parking lot from the Keystone Centre, with all proceeds going to 'Ag in the Classroom' Manitoba, so it's a great way to support a good cause while fueling up for the day ahead.”  Aside from the food, Hildebrand says it’s also a great chance to reconnect with fellow industry members.  “The

© 2025   Created by Darren Marsland.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service