Ontario Agriculture

The network for agriculture in Ontario, Canada

Finding Efficiency Through Trade Policy Change

“Give me a level playing field and we can compete with the world’s best”

I heard this quote last September 22nd at a meeting for hog farmers set up by Ontario Pork. It was one statement that I classed as optimism in a room that was overwhelmingly negative. I can completely understand why negativity abounded at this meeting, every farmer in that room faces a very uncertain future but I want to focus on the positive.
While our farm at home is one of the many hog farms that faces that uncertain future I have a calming belief that I will still farm. I truly believe that agriculture is set to take the stage as the most important global industry as we will seek for ways to feed the growing population around the world. I also believe that Canada’s role in alleviating the global food crisis will hinge on our willingness to liberalize inefficient policies that abound in Canadian ag policy.

I chose to open with that quote from the meeting because I feel that Canada would thrive in a world of free competition, there is no nation in the world better suited for agricultural production. When you couple our natural resources with our comprehensive infrastructure of supporting businesses and extensive research and knowledge bases, Canada has the potential to be an agricultural superpower. If we were ever allowed to compete in a free market, Canadian farmers would thrive. That being said, if we want a free market then we should become leaders for others around the world: step up and eliminate policies in our own country that harm producers in other regions. This attitude may not be popular with producers in certain sectors of Canadian agriculture that benefit from protectionism but I want you to consider this simple fact: Canada can produce more food that it can ever hope to consume; is it not our responsibility to explore how to make our system more efficient in hopes of feeding people around the world.

As a person coming from a free market industry, we have shown that we can compete with the world’s best. Canadian hog producers are among the lowest cost producers in the world and I firmly believe that in a world of free competition we would not be suffering right now. This feeling is probably shared by a US dairy producer facing financial ruin. It stings when you work to be a world leader in terms of efficiency, only to see your hard work destroyed by protectionist policies of your trading partners.

While my feelings on trade liberalization are probably not shared by many in the agricultural community we must consider that we are an incredibly small portion of the population and I don’t feel that it is socially responsible when we benefit at the expense of others. Consider the supply managed industries: not only do they harm the Canadian consumer; they also harm producers in other nations. Is it fair that Canadian dairy producers are making a profit because of protectionism when farmers across the border in Michigan are in danger of losing their livelihood? This problem even exists within our own borders here in Canada. Hog producers in Ontario are struggling to survive while producers in Quebec benefit from provincial subsidies and then dump their product into Ontario. If we as Canadian producers ever tried to do to other trading partners what Quebec producers do to Ontario producers we would be hit with a trade challenge the minute our goods crosses our border and the practice would have to stop.

On a larger scale, we must consider that in the global population is going to grow to 9 billion within the next 40 years with the majority of this growth coming in developing nations that lack the ability to feed themselves. While production efficiencies are important, they are only part of the equation. Efficiencies will also have to be found through the liberalization of trade. Canada has an opportunity to be a world leader in this regard. While there would be much pain for producers here in Canada in the short term if protectionist policies were eliminated, in the end it would benefit both the Canadian producer and consumers.

Views: 73


You need to be a member of Ontario Agriculture to add comments!

Join Ontario Agriculture

Comment by Christine Schoonderwoerd on October 26, 2009 at 6:34am
Great article, Stew, I always love reading your posts. I guess the obvious question here is how can we quit being on the losing end of trade barriers and Quebec's government subsidies?

Agriculture Headlines from Farms.com Canada East News - click on title for full story

Saskatchewan Pulse Growers Makes $5 Million Investment in Priority Research Areas

Saskatchewan Pulse Growers (SPG) has invested over $5 million into pulse research projects to improve productivity and reduce threats to pulse crop production.  Under the recently announced Sustainable Canadian Agricultural Partnership (CAP) AgriScience Program Clusters Component, SPG will leverage grower levy dollar investment with over $21 million of Government and other industry partner funding for the Pulse Cluster.  A complete list of projects, including researchers, and SPG’s investment can be seen below.  Selection of Early Maturing Dry Bean Germplasm and Cultivars for Sustainability and Improved Productivity Under Irrigation, Dr. Parthiba Balasubramanian, Agriculture & Agri-Food Canada (AAFC) – $50,417   Breed for Top-Performing Field Pea Varieties and Develop SNP-based Markers for Marker-Assisted Selection for Grain and Protein Yield Maturity, Standability, and Seed Size, Dr. Dengjin Bing, AAFC – $166,000  Large Root Systems in Pulses for Drought Tolerance, Carbon Sequestra

Barley Ending Stocks Expected Heavier; Wheat, Oats Lighter

Agriculture Canada is forecasting heavier barley stocks at the end of the 2023-24 crop year, but lighter inventories of wheat and oats. In its latest monthly supply-demand estimates on Friday, Ag Canada pegged barley ending stocks for the current marketing year at 1 million tonnes, up 250,000 from the January estimate and above the previous year’s 709,000 tonnes. If accurate, it would be the heaviest barley ending stocks since 2017-18 at 1.24 million tonnes. All the increase in the ending stocks estimate is due to a reduction in feed, waste, and dockage, which fell to 5.34 million tonnes from 5.59 million for both January and 2022-23. Ag Canada’s February supply-demand update reflects the Statistics Canada grain stocks report released earlier this month, which pegged national barley stocks as of Dec. 31, 2023 at 5.5 million tonnes, up 6% from a year earlier and 10% above the average, despite a smaller 2023-24 supply. The stocks report implied total domestic use of barley in the

Reduction of Advance Payment Program Interest-Free Portion raises concerns

The recent decision to reduce the interest-free portion of the Advance Payment Program (APP) from $350,000 to $100,000 has reverberated throughout the agricultural community, causing widespread apprehension among farmers and ranchers across Canada. The Advance Payment Program, a federal loan guarantee initiative, has long been a crucial lifeline for agricultural producers, offering them reliable access to low-cost cash advances to manage cash flow and navigate the uncertainties inherent in agriculture. However, the drastic reduction in the interest-free portion has heightened the financial concerns and uncertainty among farmers.Ian Boxall, president of the Agricultural Producers Association of Saskatchewan (APAS), voiced concern over the decision.  “It’s been three years since the APP interest-free portion was at $100,000, and interest rates have skyrocketed, grain prices have dramatically declined, and input prices have remained high. The program needs to reflect the current realiti

An Ounce of Prevention

Vaccines are an important tool to help minimize preweaning calf illness and death early in life, reduce the risk of reproductive failure in the breeding herd and help improve colostrum’s ability to protect next year’s calf crop when it hits the ground. Vaccine technology, programs and practices are constantly evolving. All the options can be confusing, but more options can also make it easier to customize and combine those options in a way that optimally protect your herd against the diseases that are most important to you. Dr. Cheryl Waldner and coworkers at the Western College of Veterinary Medicine studied vaccination practices from coast-to-coast in 2020 (“Vaccine use in Canadian cow-calf herds and opportunities for improvement”; DOI 10.3389/fvets.2023.1235942). What They Did Cow-calf producers from BC (6), Alberta (38), Saskatchewan (27), Manitoba (18), Ontario (20), New Brunswick (2) and Nova Scotia (2) were surveyed about which vaccines they used and when they were using them

Labour gap in Canadian ag growing

The Canadian ag sector will need as many people to work as there are in Red Deer, Alta.

© 2024   Created by Darren Marsland.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service