Ontario Agriculture

The network for agriculture in Ontario, Canada

My OMAFRA troubles and my advice to avoid them

Its never nice to hear of someone facing problems, but its useful to take advantage of the opportunity to avoid them yourself.  My opinion of OMAFRA is greatly tainted, but I am open minded enough to realize most problems could have been avoided.  

At issue is the loss of the farm tax rebate which holds municipal tax rates to, well, basically the equivalent of where they alway were.  Without the rebate, taxes quadruple.  As it stands today, my issue is only with the 2012 tax year.  So how did this happen? Well I bought a farm in 2011, my first farm.  To qualify for the tax rebate, you must have a valid FBR number (Farm Business Registration).  In previous years I didn't have an FBR number, I didn't have any land and the number serves no purpose otherwise.  I was able to farm without this, as my father had an exemption to the requirement for religious reasons applied to the farm land.  That sets the stage.

My first mistake - rather than apply for an exemption, i decided its not worth the effort, i will just conform to the system. Unfortunately, this came after September 30, which is the last day you can apply for a 2011 FBR number.  So although I contacted Agricorp in 2011, i was told i had to wait until Jan 3 to apply, which I did.  And with a bit of hassle to prove my  2011 farm activities grossed over $7,000, I was granted a 2012 FBR number.

Well, the 2012 tax rate rebate is based on the 2011 FBR number.  So when I asked OMAFRA to grant me a startup exemption, which would allow the 2012 tax rate to qualify without the prior FBR, it was denied.  Why? I sold too much grain in 2010, it was over $7,000.  I should have applied for an FBR in 2010, even though I didn't own any land.  So my families help by allowing me to ease into farming caused an issue that would not rear its head for several years.  But it could have been avoided had I applied for an exemption (and been granted) or got an FBR number.  

Now that OMAFRA will not recognize me as a startup, they can not change the tax qualification.  So they send me off to the ARB (Assessment Review Board) to file an appeal.  Its amazing that no such appeal exists in OMAFRA, if you don't like what they say, you must go through another government agency.  

In my first conversations with the ARB, I was instructed to send a letter to the chair for reconsideration.  Which was promptly denied and I was told to talk to OMAFRA.  Yea, thats where I just came from.  

So OMAFRA sends me back to the ARB, this time with a better explanation as to the process I need to follow.

So at this point, I must submit an appeal, which is not free of charge, to get this resolved, if they will even resolve it.

My advice to the new farmer in Ontario, get the FBR before you buy any land or at the very least the start up exemption.  By waiting until after, your path is littered with deadlines and forms and costs you don't need.

In defence of the people on the other end of the phone, they have all been polite and tried to help, several did note I shouldn't need to go through all this, but thats just the way it is sometimes.  

I farm because I am a farmer, I just can't stand that the government has to be so involved in this. But they have the upper hand.  All I can hope is it works out in the end.

Views: 532

Comment

You need to be a member of Ontario Agriculture to add comments!

Join Ontario Agriculture

Agriculture Headlines from Farms.com Canada East News - click on title for full story

Agriculture and agri-food events build momentum around Agriculture Enlightened conference

EMILI’s annual Agriculture Enlightened conference is taking place on October 23, 2025, at the Delta Hotel in Winnipeg. This year’s theme is Driving Agriculture Innovation. Together we’ll explore how farmers and others in the Canadian agriculture industry are adopting agtech, discuss ways to navigate the shifting global trade landscape, and connect with leaders advancing innovation across Canada. A number of EMILI’s partners are hosting amazing agriculture and agri-food events the same week as Agriculture Enlightened 2025. Whether you’re looking for something to do ahead of Agriculture Enlightened or continue networking afterwards, check out these upcoming events.   Young Entrepreneurs Awards Hosted by MEIA, League of Innovators, and Manitoba Innovates Wednesday, October 22, 4:30pm – 9:00pm Location: The Metropolitan Entertainment Centre 400+ nominations, 6 awards, and 1 big night to celebrate Canada’s greatest young entrepreneurs and the future of sustainability! Purchase tickets

St. Benedict educator and farmer receives Farm and Food Care Saskatchewan’s Champion Award

For the past decade, Farm & Food Care Saskatchewan recognizes a person who strives to engage consumers about agriculture and helps farmers build public trust in our province and beyond. The Champion Award was presented Tuesday morning in Saskatoon to Sandra Hessdorfer from St. Benedict. Sandra, her husband and two teenage sons have a grain farm and black angus cattle. Her off-farm job is the Ag Education Officer with the Horizon School Division. Her duties include delivering presentations, supporting school programs, and organizing an annual Student Ag Day for all Grade 10 students. The event is held in Humboldt and attracted 570 students and their teachers from across the Horizon School Division, which is the largest by area in the province. Hessdorfer is also a past-chair of Women in Ag and has been active with Ag in the Classroom and Saskatchewan 4-H. CJWW Agriculture Director Neil Billinger spoke to Sandra shortly after she received her award.

Indefinite pause placed on Crown land sales

A two-year moratorium on Crown land sales expired in August, and plans were made for an October auction which had already been advertised online. Nearly 4,500 acres of cultivated and grazing farmland was split into 18 lots. That sale is being paused at the request of the Ministry of Agriculture. There has been opposition voiced by the NDP and Indigenous people. Late last week, Premier Scott Moe told reporters “it was a case of where we just got a little bit ahead of ourselves in that process starting again.” In a statement, the Government of Saskatchewan explained the parcels of land that were going up for auction had previously been leased agricultural land where the leases had been surrendered or cancelled.

Mustard millers relish investment tax credit

G.S. Dunn Limited (G.S. Dunn) is investing approximately $30 million to grow its mustard milling facility in Bow Island supported by a $3.1 million Agri-Processing Investment Tax Credit (APITC) from Alberta’s government. The project has created 34 new jobs and allowed G.S. Dunn to access two new markets in Japan and South Korea. The expansion will also increase its purchase of raw mustard seed from $13 million to $44 million with all seed coming from western Canada. “Investors continue to choose Alberta as a place to establish roots, grow and expand because it makes good business sense. The Agri-Processing Investment Tax Credit is just one of the ways our government commits to creating ideal conditions for businesses while attracting investment, diversifying the economy and creating more jobs for Albertans.” RJ Sigurdson, Minister of Agriculture and Irrigation The Bow Island expansion is the second phase of G.S. Dunn’s value-added mustard milling project. Since its initial expansion

Canada Post strike affecting Harvest Sample Program

Farmers can drop off harvest samples in person at multiple locations

© 2025   Created by Darren Marsland.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service