Ontario Agriculture

The network for agriculture in Ontario, Canada

The CFFO Commentary: Discussing the Merits and Reforms of Marketing Systems

By John Clement
September 23, 2011
 
Over the past few weeks, my colleague Nathan Stevens has been discussing different dimensions of supply managed marketing systems for agricultural products. In particular, he’s been responding to comments made by Andrew Coyne, a columnist for MacLean’s magazine. As the commentary series progressed, we had a number of readers correspond with us about why the organization chooses to become involved in a debate about supply management.
 
It should be noted that the views contained within the CFFO Commentary are those of the author and don’t necessarily represent the organization’s policy. But that being said, it should also be noted that the CFFO has not been a stranger to debates about the merits of different types of marketing systems. In fact, debates about the fairness of supply management have been frequent over several decades, with members not shy about expressing their opinions about the system. Here is a sampling of just a few diverse comments assembled from our earliest official position statements at the CFFO:
 
·         In 1974, the organization said “The Christian Farmers Federation sees supply management as a tool which can be used effectively against injustice, misuse of power, opportunism, unfair competition, and low returns to family farmers. When thus used, the Christian Farmers Federation will endorse supply management programs. But there is no built-in guarantee that the power that comes with this tool will in fact be used in this way; just as an axe, though great for splitting wood, has no inherent qualities that will keep it from being used to split heads.”
·         In 1976, the organization said “In commodities where long-term incomes are adequate or where no major injustices exist for family farm producers, supply management is too drastic a stabilizing measure.”
·         In 1980, the organization said “farmers have a history of contributing their return to investment back to the industry in some form. This is a basic cause of high quota values. The fact that farmers do this does not destroy the legitimacy of a return on investment.”
·         In 1981, the organization said “we continue to express our concern about the unacceptably high dairy quota values.”
 
That tradition of accepting the numerous benefits of supply managed systems, while also being committed to both thoughtful criticism and reform of those systems, has been a hallmark of the CFFO and continues to this day. Our members regularly meet and discus items related to the structure of their industries, with an eye towards making them work better. And other marketing systems, like those used for hogs, have regularly drawn the attention of the organization.
 
I don’t see discussions on supply management, nor discussions on what improvements can be made, disappearing any time soon from within the life of the CFFO. In fact, it’s likely that thoughtful dialogue will continue on for years to come.
 
John Clementis the General Manager of the Christian Farmers Federation of Ontario. The CFFO Commentary represents the opinions of the writer and does not necessarily represent CFFO policy. The CFFO Commentary is heard weekly on CFCO Chatham, CKNX Wingham, and UCB Canada radio stations in Chatham, Belleville, Bancroft, Brockville and Kingston. It is also archived on the CFFO website: www.christianfarmers.org. CFFO is supported by 4,200 family farmers across Ontario.

Views: 59

Comment

You need to be a member of Ontario Agriculture to add comments!

Join Ontario Agriculture

Agriculture Headlines from Farms.com Canada East News - click on title for full story

Chinese Tariffs Are Squeezing Canadian Grain and Oilseeds

Canada has just been hit with Chinese tariffs, canola meal and oil exports to China are valued at $920.9 million

Kody Blois appointed minister of agriculture in Carney’s cabinet

Canada’s new ag minister is from Nova Scotia

Voting Quorum Changed to Ensure APG Meetings Continue to Move Forward with Commission Business

The Alberta Pulse Growers Commission (APG) changed its bylaws to reduce the number of members necessary to conduct an annual or special Commission meeting from 40 to 30 eligible producers. The Alberta Agricultural Products Marketing Council approved the change on February 24 following a vote by eligible APG members attending the 2025 annual general meeting in January and conversations at all five fall zone meetings. “We had great turnout at the provincial AGM in January, but sometimes it isn’t easy to get growers out to these meetings,” said APG Chair Shane Strydhorst, who farms at Neerlandia. “If we didn’t have quorum at the AGM, we wouldn’t have been able to hold a vote and would have had to reschedule. We strive for more than our quorum number when we are making decisions because we want everyone to participate.” Strydhorst added that the board agreed that the move was necessary for several reasons, including the increasing consolidation of farms. The new quorum number brings APG

Canada’s Pulse Industry Calls For Swift Resolution To The Imposition Of Chinese Tariffs

Yesterday, the Chinese Ministry of Commerce announced the results of its anti-discrimination investigation into Canada for imposing a 100% tariff on EVs and an additional 25% tariff on steel and aluminum products imported from China. As a result of this investigation the State Council Tariff Commission will impose an additional 100% tariff on Canadian peas, canola oil and canola meal as well as an additional 25% tariff on Canadian pork and seafood. “China is one of Canada’s largest markets for yellow peas; a market that Canadian farmers and exporters have been serving since the mid 1990’s,” said Terry Youzwa, Chair of Pulse Canada. “The Canadian industry values this long-standing and mutually beneficial partnership. We know Chinese customers prefer Canadian peas and want to continue to deal with Canadian suppliers.” In 2024, Canada exported roughly 500,000 metric tonnes of yellow peas valued at over $306M. The 5-year average for yellow pea exports is over 1,500,000 metric tonnes valu

Grain Farmers Caught in Crossfire as U.S.-China Trade War Escalates

Tariffs threaten billions in exports, family farms at risk, Grain Growers of Canada says. Canadian grain farmers are facing a trade crisis on two fronts, with escalating tariffs from both the United States and China threatening billions in exports and putting the future of family farms at exceptional risk, Grain Growers of Canada (GGC) says. The Chinese government’s decision to impose 100 percent tariffs on Canadian canola oil, canola meal, and peas comes as trade tensions with the U.S. continue to pressure Canada’s grain sector. “With uncertainty mounting with the United States, our largest export market, the last thing grain farmers needed was a trade war with China, our second largest export market,” said Kyle Larkin, Executive Director of GGC. “Together, the U.S. and China account for over half of all Canadian grain exports — losing access or facing exorbitant tariffs in both markets at once is a threat farmers cannot afford to absorb.” GGC echo the concerns raised by the Canadi

© 2025   Created by Darren Marsland.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service